CSKA
Is AI the Future?
Going into the season Malcolm's rankings (rightfully so) had CSKA pegged for relegation. We were surprisingly promoted into D1 and from a ratings standpoint don't have much business being there.
But did AI know something we didn't? AI said with our GK (Carnesecchi) and depth we may well survive. After 25 games, CSKA has 32 points, good for 13th place and with a 10 point cushion to relegation. Could we still be relegated? Of course! We're just not that good (yet). But Memphis Depay, Ciro Immobile and perhaps our first signing Simon Adingra and a great D have kept us in games a bit. We're exceeding expectations
We have a weird team where most of our starters are 30+ and everyone else is u21 with a few exceptions. The updates will help somewhat - Martin and Jimenez may well be startable soon but with so maybe oldies we're due some drops as well.
CSKA already has more points than I was likely expecting. It will be an interesting final 1/3 of the season. Even if we survive we'll be battling relegation for several seasons without some big moves. But the goal is always to win D1 not just survive.
CSKA: A Taste of D1
In September, I wrote that CSKA was heading to D2 for the first time since Season 14, well before I took over. My goal was to stay up, and the stats indicated that CSKA was in the hunt for relegation. Fast forward to the end of the season and CSKA is being promoted to D1 for the first time ever!! We'll be odds-on favorites for relegation. There are a few cards we could play. Accept that we'll be underdogs in every game, trade in our impressive youth team, or see how we fare through the first third of the season and decide on what chips to play. I don't want to tear down our team for short-term benefits. But I also want to be more Sunderland than Luton Town. At the end of the day, we're still in a transition period with only 3 players above 90 (Carnesecchi, Maguire, Carreras) and were quite lucky to get to D1 so soon.
GK: We have starting GK Carnesecchi (90) entering his prime. Mycael may be our starting youth GK or he may leave - it depends on the deals we make and what room we have. Behind him is Miguel Gouveia, a top Portuguese GK prospect.
RB: Alexander Bah (88), the oft-injured Benfica starter is our starter after we jettisoned KWP. Primary backup is a rotation of two 85 youth players Alex Jimenez and Jon Martin, though neither may be a RB as his primary position. Okoduwa and Jean Mambuku are ones for the future.
CB: Harry Maguire (90) remains the starter with fan favorite Chris Richards (88), from nearby Alabama. Mamadou Sarr (87) and Jan-Carlo Simic (85) continue to progress nicely. We have a few players who can cover here: Jon Martin, Alvaro Carreras, and Lerma. There is a significant amount of young depth between Tyler Meiser, Freddie Simmonds, Baba Kourouma, and Ben Hawighorst, Ishe-Samuels Smith, and Ngana. This may be an area to trade youth for experience.
LB: Alvaro Carreras (90) seems to be the locked in Madrid starter, though it's one of many clubs in turmoil. Kiernan Tierney was also sold this season. Our primary backup is now Alex Jimenez (85).
DM: Jordan Henderson (89) continues to start alongside Pape Gueye (88). Lerma and Romeo Lavia (87) will be backups. This is an area that had a lot of turnover in the youth ranks. Gone are the Senegalese duo. We retain Ze Lucas, Bouabre, and Sekou Kone. We've also added Rafa Quintas, Pereira da Gama, Dierckx, and Samba. A lot of young players getting first-team minutes and likely a position that will entirely turnover in the first team in the coming seasons.
CM: Brazilian Matheus Pereira (88) has taken over for Ziyech. Kendry (85) is his primary backup though he is often spotted smoking hookah at the local square dancing bar. Memphis Depay was brought in to challenge in this spot as well. Many of the DM youth qualify here as do players like Odobert and Isaque.
AM: Iago Aspas (89) and Adingra (88) continue to be starters. Bertrand Traore is the main backup with Mastantuono. Odobert continues to wait for Traore and Aspas to falter. Irankunda, Cavan Sullivan, Isaque, and Ndala remain key youth players.
CF: Ciro Immobile (89) is the starter, though his downgrade is only a matter of time. Aspas and Memphis can fill in here as well. This position remains more potential than results with Danns, Konate, N'guessan, and Bro Hansen all fighting injury or youth.
Marketing: The lure of D1 should be enough to get the Texan crowd away from football and into futbol.
Likely starting lineup: Carnesecchi, Bah, Maguire, Richards, Carreras, Gueye, Henderson, Pereira, Aspas, Adingra, Immobile.
Youth lineup: Mycael, Martin, Sarr, Simic, Jimenez, Ze Lucas, Paez, Irankunda, Mastantuono, Odobert, Konate
Goal: Either stay up or avoid complete embarrassment
CSKA Season 26 - A Return to D2
Season 25 saw a D3 title and promotion D2. As David stated, the jump from D3 to D2 is steep, but CSKA has greater ambitions than even D2 and hope not to regress in season 26. This will be CSKA's first season in D2 under Chris Meida and its first season in D2 since season 14. It has never made an appearance in D1.
GK: We have starting GK Carnesecchi (90) who continues to be solid for Atalanta and is one of the top young GKs in the world. Behind him is Mycael, consistent starter who Brazil U20 and once one of the top GK prospects in the world. However, he's lost his spot in Serie B and will be aging out of the youth team after this season. Behind him we've brought in Miguel Gouveia, a top Portuguese GK prospect.
RB: A two way battle between new West Ham signing Kyle Walker Peters (88) and Alexander Bah (88), the oft-injured Benfica starter. Behind those two are youth players Alex Jimenez (83), new Cherries signing from Milan with a Real Madrid buyback, and Wes Okoduwa, who I believe can develop into a lockdown defender but may need to add to his offensive repertoire. Jean Mambuku is a wild card behind them and Eric da Silva Moreira has now moved to Portugal on loan.
CB: Harry Maguire (90) aka Dursley starts with either Palace starter Chris Richards or Martin Valjent (87s). We continue to have a youth movement at the position. Mamadou Sarr and Jan-Carlo Simic are both 85s and starters at Strasbourg and Anderlecht. Jon Martin (82) is a rotational starter at Sociedad. There is a significant amount of young depth between Tyler Meiser, Freddie Simmonds, Baba Kourouma, and Ben Hawighorst.
LB: Alvaro Carreras (88) has finally claimed the starting spot and has been off to a terrific start for Real Madrid. Kiernan Tierney is his backup. We've recently signed Ishe Samuels-Smith with an eye toward the future. He had been a long-time target of CSKA. In the youth cup Jimenez is likely to switch over here with Jon Martin playing RB.
DM: Jordan Henderson (89) will start the season alongside Pape Gueye (88). The oft-injured Romeo Lavia (87) will be backup as his progress has stagnated. The manager believes he still has the potential to be amongst the best at his position. Celtic captain Callum McGregor (87) is a good depth piece as well. From a youth perspective, we have Sekou Kone at Man United and compatriot Hamidou Makalou. Ze Lucas, Pape Diong and Saimon Bouabre, now amongst Neom's French connection are the youth options.
CM: Hakim Ziyech (88) holds down the starting spot with Brazilian Matheus Pereira (87) behind him. Kendry is finally old enough to be in Europe. Lorran has left for greener pastures and we now see Shakhtar-bound Isaque in his role.
AM: Iago Aspas (89) and Adingra (88) continue to be starters. Bertrand Traore is the main backup. Madrid newboy Mastantuono and Odobert are the main backups. Irankunda is off to a hot start at Watford and Cavan Sullivan continues to impress despite being so young he has barely piqued Trump's interest. Joel Ndala has been brought in through the Lorran trade.
CF: Ciro Immobile (89) is the undisputed starter. We have a few players who can pop in as backup from other positions. Karim Konate should be returning soon from his torn ACL. Jayden Danns stuck around Liverpool this offseason, which was surprising. We continue to be excited by N'guessan and Bro Hansen's potential as they see some gametime.
Marketing: The “Bro” campaign was a huge success last year. With HBO releasing the Harry Potter series in the near future and captain Harry Maguire's uncanny resemblance to Dursley, he is appearing in our new marketing campaign: "Snuggles with Muggles."
Likely starting lineup: Carnesecchi, Bah, Maguire, Richards, Carreras, Gueye, Henderson, Ziyech, Aspas, Adingra, Immobile.
Youth lineup: Mycael, Martin, Sarr, Simic, Jimenez, Lavia, Paez, Irankunda, Mastantuano, Odobert, Konate
A Party in the USA
CSKA Moscow TX fans were ecstatic as they witnessed their team lift the D3 trophy on Saturday. The second August trophy after lifting the Youth Shield was one for the ages. Lifting the trophy were the elder statesman and three top scorers: Immobile, Aspas, and Ziyech. Fan favorite and 26 assist man Simon Adingra was swarmed by celebrities and flanked by leading appearance GK Carnesecchi.
Season tickets have already sold out for next season - the team's first in division 2 since season 4.
"We've had a few of the new guys crack the starting lineup - Carreras, Adingra, Lavia - but in order to succeed in a division with such great managers we'll need more of the new generation to step up and help supplement our veteran core."
Interviewed after the game, captain Harry Maguire said, "We went into the game with the burden of expectations and having President Putin in the stands just added to the weight. But as soon as I saw Sydney Sweeney front row, I knew things would be all right."
CSKA: Season 25
We enter our 3rd consecutive season in division 3, which is a fine accomplishment and a step up from where we found the team. But the manager, the fans, and the private equity group all envision a D1 team. After all, no one manages a club or a buys a club for them to flounder in mediocrity. Below is a recap of where the team stands heading into season 25 and the upcoming ratings updates.
Season 24 at the midway point we were in relegation territory. We added Iago Aspas, Ciro Immobile, and Stefan Savic to shore the team up and we rose to the playoff spots only to lose out on goal differential on the last day.
GK: We have starting GK Carnesecchi (90) who is having a great season domestically and in the Champions League. We sold Majecki to Hamburg as he didn't seem likely to overtake Carnesecchi - he was doing well for Monaco at the time of sale, which made it painful, but has slipped a bit since. Youth GK Mycael (80) is starting in Serie B and in the Brazilian youth teams. He is a PK specialist and modern GK who could draw a move to Europe.
RB: A two way battle between pending free agent Kyle Walker Peters (88) and Alexander Bah (88), stalwart in the Benfica side. Behind those two are youth players Alex Jimenez (76), now a rotational Milan player, and Wes Okoduwa, who I believe can develop into a lockdown defender but may need to add to his offensive repertoire.
CB: We have two aging starters in Harry Maguire (90) and Stefan Savic (88). Gone are the retired Varane and long-time captain Coates. Behind them are Chris Richards (87) and Martin Valjent (87), who are solid with some potential. Youth team players Jon Martin, Jan-Carlo Simic, Mamadou Sarr, and Tarek Buchmann hold down the fort. Simic and Sarr should be in for hefty rises given their starting spots at Anderlecht and Strasbourg. Buchmann continues to battle injury. We've also added German youth international Tyler Meiser.
LB: Caio Henrique was sold this week to Celtic for Tierney and 2 Brazilian youths. He had been performing well for Monaco and is a big loss. Taking his place is Kieran Tierney (88), spot player for Arsenal when healthy, and on his way to Celtic. Alvaro Carreras has been a standout for Benfica and should see a summer move and a rating increase. He is our long-term starter. We've also added Ben Hawighorst for the future at CB/LB.
DM: Jordan Henderson (89) will start the season alongside oft-injured Romeo Lavia (87). Pape Gueye (87) is consistently starting for Villareal and Celtic captain Callum McGregor (87) is a good depth piece as well. From a youth perspective, we have Sekou Kone at Man United, compatriot Hamidou Makalou finally made his move to France and was on the team sheet on Day 1. Staying in France, Pape Diong has the profile I like in Strasbourg and Saimon Bouabre should be getting more game time in my opinion. We've also added Brazil U17 captain Ze Lucas.
CM: We recently added Hakim Ziyech (88) with Brazilian Matheus Pereira (87) behind him. A lot of youth talent should raise the ceiling soon with Kendry, Mastantuono, and Lorran all making varying degrees of progress.
AM: We brought in Iago Aspas (89) to pair with Adingra (88). Laborde and Bertrand Traore are the main backups and have been getting plenty of game time. Odobert has recovered and is getting time for Spurs. We're transitioning the youth at this position knowing our CMs can play here as well. Irankunda and Cavan Sullivan remain, while we've added Isaque, Oscar Perea, and Mathis Lambourde.
CF: We brought in Ciro Immobile (90) and Jamie Vardy (88). Cognizant they are aging, we have a few options in the holster, Karim Konate, Jayden Danns are the nearest options (Laborde is a true CF as well). We've also signed 2 players we're excited about: N'Guessan and Mikkel Bro Hansen.
Marketing: The "Bro" campaign featuring Mikkel Bro Hansen has been a big hit with American youth. He was recently on the Joe Rogan podcast and Barstool Sports. While the manager questions these media outlets, he has been assured by the private equity group that the message of a (former) Russian club really resonates with this audience.
Likely starting lineup: Carnesecchi, Bah, Maguire, Savic, Tierney, Lavia, Henderson, Ziyech, Aspas, Adingra, Immobile.
Youth lineup: Mycael, Martin, Sarr, Simic, Jimenez, Lavia, Paez, Lorran, Mastantuano, Odobert, Konate
CSKA Entering Season 24
We enter our 2nd consecutive season in division 3. The Brazilian ratings were kind to us with a +13 for Lorran, Matheus Pereira possibly entering our starting lineup, and our starting youth GK Mycael rising to 80. It is tough to write this post with many unknowns since rating updates have just started, but in order to engage our audience in the US (and possibly our original home in Russia as the two countries may be joining forces).
GK: We have starting GK Carnesecchi (88) who is having a good season domestically and in the Champions League. He has not forced his way into the Italy team, though that will be a future goal. Backup GK is Majecki - back from injury and starting for Monaco, also in the CL. It is a luxury to have 2 U25 GKs in the CL and it is possible one of the two will force a transfer. Mycael is also starting for cellar dwellars Paranaense. The Brazil U20 GK has drawn comparisons to Ederson and one can only hope he continues to progress. He certainly faces enough shots!
RB: A two way battle between Kyle Walker Peters (soon to be a free agent?) and Alexander Bah, stalwart in the Benfica side. Behind those two are youth players Alex Jimenez, who has struggled for minutes in Milan but should have a bright future with Madrid's buy back clause, and Wes Okoduwa, who this American manager hopes will switch his allegiance from England to the US (fun fact: 4 U17 England callups today have American eligibility).
CB: We sent two promising prospects to Levante for Varane. No regrets as he helped solidify our place in D3. However, his unexpected retirement has hurt CB depth. Our two starters will be Harry Maguire (you all may be more familiar with him as Dursley in the Harry Potter movies) and former Sporting captain Sebastian Coates. Behind them are Chris Richards and Martin Valjent, both fairly promising CBs who hold our floor at 87. Youth team players Jon Martin, Jan-Carlo Simic, Mamadou Sarr, and Tarek Buchmann hold down the fort. Simic and Sarr should be in for hefty rises given their starting spots at Anderlecht and Strasbourg. Buchmann may be the most talented of the bunch if he can stay healthy.
LB: Caio Henrique is back from his ACL tear and returning to form. Behind him temporarily is Max Wober. Alvaro Carreras is the new hot thing at Benfica. A very graceful player with a bright future, perhaps back at United. Christian McFarlane, another UK/US dual nat, is on the move to City in January. He has drawn comparisons to Antonee Robinson and was the fastest player in MLS at the ripe age of 17.
At DM, we have two oldies holding down fort. Daler Kuzyaev and Jordan Henderson will start the season on the team sheet. Behind them are fast rising Romeo Lavia, who may have overtaken Enzo certainly as a role model and possibly at Chelsea as well. Pape Gueye seems to acclimating to Spanish football after his suspension last year in France. A number of African prospects are in the youth side, including Super Samp loanee from Inter Akinsanmiro, Makalou - silver ball winner and soon to be Brest player, Pape Diong, another Strasbourg signee, and Sekou Kone, another United prospect. Saimon Bouabre, the silky playmaker for French youth teams, may also slot into this position.
At CM, Matheus Pereira and Callum McGregor battle for the starting point. Hot prospects Mastantuano and Lorran battle behind them, with wildcard Roger Gabriel also slotted in.
On the Wings we have Adingra and Laborde as starters. Traore and Ayew are the main backups. Kendry and Odobert should break into the team soon. Top Australian prospect Irankunda shows tremendous ball striking and speed, Cavan Sullivan is likely the next Pulisic, with the manager waiting to see what Olivio Tome and Luka Andrade can bring to the table.
Forward will likely have Ayew or Laborde at some point during the season. Until then it is up to player of the season Cavani to hold down the fort with Golden Boy Konate showing potential. Jayden Daans and Jovan Milosevic are also part of the squad.
Likely starting lineup: Carnesecchi, Walker Peters, Maguire, Coates, Caio Henrique, Kuzyaev, Henderson, Pereira, Laborde, Adingra, Cavani.
Youth lineup: Mycael, Martin, Sarr, Simic, Alvaro, Lavia, Paez, Lorran, Mastantuano, Irankunda, Konate







