By David Marsden · Hamburger SV

Twenty-two players rated 89 to 94, all of them once on Hamburg’s books, all of them sold. Put the best eleven together and they’d be among the favourites for the Division 1 title. Hamburg, meanwhile, are back in Division 2 again.


After relegation, I did what every sensible manager does after a bad season. I went looking for something to make me feel worse.

I scrolled through the transfer history of every 89+ rated player in Top 100 and counted the ones who used to play for Hamburg.

It took a while.


The Lost XI

Position Player Sold At Now
GK Lukáš Hrádecký Aug 2020 89 89
RB Pedro Porro Jan 2020 85 91
CB Willian Pacho Jun 2023 87 93
CB Maxence Lacroix Aug 2025 88 90
LB Diogo Dalot Jan 2021 85 90
DM Moisés Caicedo Oct 2022 85 93
DM Angelo Stiller Dec 2023 87 91
AM Morgan Gibbs-White May 2024 87 91
RW Antoine Semenyo Dec 2023 83 92
LW João Pedro Apr 2022 82 91
CF Julián Álvarez Dec 2019 78 94
Average 91.4

Hamburg’s Lost XI in a 4-2-3-1: eleven players Hamburg sold, now averaging 91.4

Lined up in our usual 4-2-3-1 B, the Lost XI averages 91.4. Our actual first team averages 89.5.

The ones that got away are nearly two points better than the ones that stayed.


The Bench

And they wouldn’t even need the subs bench to be any good. Yet it is:

Player Pos Sold At Now
Bryan Mbeumo AM/F Jul 2021 83 91
John McGinn M/AM Aug 2016 81 91
Giorgio Scalvini D/DM Jan 2022 75 90
Mario Gila D Dec 2022 78 90
Johnny Cardoso DM/M Mar 2023 82 90
Kang-In Lee M/AM Oct 2022 85 90
Mohammed Kudus AM/F Sep 2022 83 90
Pascal Gross D/DM/M Dec 2017 87 90
Waldemar Anton D Mar 2017 82 90
Marc Pubill D Aug 2022 76 89
Samu Aghehowa F Dec 2023 82 89

Scalvini is 22. Pubill is 23. Aghehowa is 22. They’ll be better than most of my current squad for years.


Paying Them to Leave

The worst part isn’t who I sold. It’s what I sold them for.

The usual story goes like this: a promising youngster, rated in the low-to-mid 80s, swapped for an established star whose best days were about to be behind him. That trade sounds sensible at the time. It rarely is.

Sometimes I didn’t even get the star for free. In several deals Hamburg added cash to the youngster:

  • Angelo Stiller, Georginio Rutter and £20m for Mason Mount.
  • Moisés Caicedo and £12m for Mason Greenwood.
  • Mohammed Kudus and £10m for Lorenzo Insigne.
  • Kang-In Lee and £5m for Alex Oxlade-Chamberlain.
  • Giorgio Scalvini and £3.2m, for a player who no longer appears in the database.
  • Marc Pubill and £2.4m for Danny Ward.
  • João Pedro and £1m for Sebastian Walukiewicz.
  • Pedro Porro and £1m, again for a player who has since vanished.

Some of those players helped at the time. One of them, Greenwood, is still my best winger. But in total I paid more than £50m to give away seven players who are now rated 90 or higher.


Lacroix: Once Bitten, Twice Sold

Maxence Lacroix deserves his own section.

I sold him to Anderlecht in May 2022, rated 87, for Clément Lenglet and Luís Pizzi.

In March 2025 I bought him back from Bayern, now 88, for £2m and Tomás Araújo.

Five months later I sold him again, to Lokomotiv Moskva, for Aleix García.

He’s now 90.

If he ever becomes available again, someone please stop me.


The Gibbs-White Chain

Some mistakes come in pairs.

In March 2023 I swapped Johnny Cardoso (82) and £800k for Morgan Gibbs-White. A year later I swapped Gibbs-White (87) for Thomas Müller.

Cardoso is now 90. Gibbs-White is now 91. Müller is still playing, and is still 90 rated.

Two future 90s for one season of a German legend in decline. He was crap for me as well.


In My Defence

Not every sale was a blunder.

Wojciech Szczęsny was rated 91 when I sold him to Schalke in August 2024 for £7.8m and Dani Rodríguez. He’d just announced his retirement, and it was the only deal on the table.

A few weeks later Barcelona talked him out of retirement.

He’s since dropped to 89, so I can live with that one, but it was annoying at the time.

Lukáš Hrádecký was 89 when he left for Inter in 2020. He’s 89 now after rising to 90 and dropping back again. Not every name on this list is a mistake. Just most of them.


On the Plus Side

There is one thing this list proves: I can spot a player.

Nine of them cost Hamburg less than £1.5m each, bought from external clubs or straight off the new-player list:

Player Signed Fee Now
Maxence Lacroix Jan 2020, Sochaux £399k 90
Pedro Porro Jun 2018, Girona £479k 91
Moisés Caicedo Mar 2020, Independiente del Valle £479k 93
Samu Aghehowa Aug 2023, Granada £479k 89
Giorgio Scalvini May 2021, new player £599k 90
Mario Gila Jan 2022, Valencia £600k 90
Waldemar Anton May 2016, Hannover £639k 90
Julián Álvarez Jan 2019, new player £1.4m 94
John McGinn Feb 2016, Hibernian £1.4m 91

That’s £6.5m for nine players now rated 89 to 94.

The scouting was never the problem. The patience was. Although to be fair much of the loss can be partly explained by failed attempts to win the Youth Cup followed by separate attempts to win promotion after relegation. As well as not really know what I’m doing 🤦🏻.


The Lesson

Look at the “At” column again. Álvarez went at 78. Gila at 78. Scalvini at 75. Pubill at 76. João Pedro, Cardoso and Aghehowa at 82.

The pattern is obvious, and so is the rule I’m now trying to live by:

Don’t sell a rising youngster unless an 88+ under 25 comes back.

Selling the veterans at their peak is fine. Selling the kids before they peak is how you end up writing posts like this.


What Happens Next

This season I’ve finally started doing it the other way round. The 35-year-old centre-backs have gone. The youngsters are staying.

Joane Gadou has just gone up to 85. Lucas Herrington, Kees Smit, Breno Bidon, Tobiáš Pališčák and Huguinho are all rising.

The offers are already coming in.

The answer, for once, is no.

Ask me again in five years whether I’ve learned anything. Or just check this list.