Top Performers and Underachievers in Season 25

Top 100 Season 25 Six Match Review

Six matches into Season 25, the highly competitive Top 100 game world is already offering plenty of intrigue. It’s still early in the 38-game campaign (current in-game date Thu 1 May 2025), but comparing the action to pre-season expectations (including “Malcolm’s Stats” by Sevilla manager Mister TRX, 8th historically), historical manager performance, and last season’s trophy winners reveals some fascinating early narratives. Here’s an overview of who’s hitting the ground running, who’s stumbling, and potential reasons why.

Division 1: São Paulo Lead; Reigning Champs Verona Off Pace

Fittingly, the game world’s top-ranked manager historically, Scott Mckenzie, has São Paulo leading (16 pts), though he acknowledged needing more despite staying unbeaten after a 2-2 draw at Sporting. Just behind are kevin mcgregor’s Juventus (15 pts, 39th historically), last season’s Top 100 Shield winners, who suffered their first loss 1-2 at home against Doug Earle’s impressive Leicester (6th). McGregor admitted he “would of bitten your hand off if said this was the start I was going to get,” showing perspective despite the setback. Adam’s Barcelona (5th, 40th historically, S24 Super Cup winners) also look dangerous, spearheaded by the sensational G. Rodrygo (leading D1 with 5 goals and 6 assists). Manager Adam noted his key attackers are “getting amongst the goals more… hope they can keep it going.”

The biggest divergence from Malcolm’s Stats is the form of Dario Saviano’s Dortmund (17th, 28th historically) and, more surprisingly, Luís André Libras-Boas’s Hellas Verona (12th, 5th historically). Predicted as title contenders, their struggles are stark – especially for Verona as reigning Division 1 champions. It suggests either the pre-season analysis overrated their readiness or established managers are finding the tactical battles tougher this term. Even James Mckenzie (2nd historically, S24 SMFA Shield winner) finds Chelsea slightly off pace in 8th. Fellow S24 trophy winners André Guerra (Porto, SMFA Champions Cup – 10th) also sit mid-table.

How are last season’s promoted sides adapting? Last season’s D2 champions Aston Villa (David Inglis, 18th historically) are currently 14th. D2 play-off winners Tottenham (Pedro Vilar, 67th) are exceeding early expectations in 11th after beating Espanyol 3-2, a result Mullan (Espanyol) felt robbed by. Regan Thompson’s Hertha BSC (44th historically), S24 Top 100 Cup winners, are currently 18th.

At the bottom, Gursimran Brar (11th historically) sees Köln last as forecast, while Espanyol and Hertha join them. Espanyol’s Mullan expressed frustration after the Spurs loss, citing hitting the post multiple times and injuries.

Division 2: Leverkusen Deliver, West Brom Flounder, Schick Flies

Marco G’s Leverkusen (1st, 16 pts, 59th historically) are impressively living up to their favourites tag from the predictions, dispatching Udinese 4-1 with Koopmeiners (7 goals) instrumental. Behind them are Standard Liège (2nd, 12 pts), managed by Attilio Bonnici (69th historically), who are performing well after winning the D3 title last season, despite a shock 1-0 loss at Genoa. For 3rd place Hamburger SV, manager David Marsden (41st historically) felt they “Totally dominated a strong Stoke side” but needed a late Casemiro goal for a 1-1 draw. Atlético (Gav Harmer) and Stoke (Andrew Kelly, 4th historically) are also in the mix.

The season’s biggest shock remains paddy d’s West Brom (16th historically). Tipped for glory by the stats, now rooted in 20th. This drastic underperformance raises questions about their high-profile recruitment strategy. Conversely, RJ Alston’s Southampton (8th, 24th historically) and Jamie Alldridge’s Schalke (12th, 35th) are comfortably mid-table, defying predictions of a relegation scrap. Man Utd (Dan Wallace, 25th) are struggling near the bottom (17th) as expected during their rebuild phase.

Last season’s D3 play-off winners Udinese Calcio (6th), managed by Neil Frankland (23rd historically), are also competing effectively in the top half after promotion.

Individuals: Benfica’s Patrik Schick is the standout scorer across all divisions with 9 goals, while Southampton’s Houssem Aouar leads D2 assists with 8.

Division 3: CSKA & Flamengo Top; Dnipro Still Surprise

Newer manager Chris Meida (71st) has CSKA leading (1st, 15 pts), alongside Carl Martin’s Flamengo (55th historically), though Flamengo stumbled with a shock 3-0 loss at Saint-Etienne, with Martin citing key player absences. Mike Scallotti (10th historically) has Everton (3rd, 13 pts) well-placed, fulfilling their predicted potential.

The remarkable story is Everton Luiz’s Dnipro (5th, 11 pts, 81st historically). Tipped for relegation by Malcolm’s Stats, their strong start suggests effective tactics or perhaps being underestimated. Fiorentina’s D. Mota leads scoring (6 goals) but his team (15th) underwhelms. Predicted promotion candidates Anderlecht (Walter Gogh, 27th) and PSG (Josh McMillan, 21st) need improvement.

How are last season’s promoted teams settling into D3? Zenit Saint Petersburg (4th), managed by Christian RC 1914 (82nd) after winning D4 last year, have adapted excellently. AS Saint-Etienne (13th), under Carlos Miranda (77th) and promoted via D4 play-off, showed their potential by beating Flamengo.

At the bottom, Chris Mackenzie’s Basel (52nd historically) struggle as predicted, joined by Hoffenheim and Shakhtar.

Division 4: Predictions in Disarray as New Leaders Emerge

This division completely contradicts the pre-season forecast. ruts66 (7th historically) leads with Feyenoord (14 pts), alongside Stuart Monteith’s Montpellier (14 pts, 56th historically). Dynamo Moskva (Paul Rimmer, 59th) are 3rd, performing as predicted for a playoff spot. Córdoba, Salah, and Blanco share the goals lead (5).

The biggest head-scratchers are Mister TRX’s Sevilla (8th historically, now 17th) and Hugo Costa’s Celtic (50th historically, now 14th). Despite TRX crafting the very stats predicting his team for the title, he admits “things haven’t really gone to plan.” Are the established managers/squads struggling tactically, or were they simply overrated? Conversely, Melvin Udall’s Werder Bremen (5th, relatively new, 91st) are defying their relegation prediction admirably.

Two teams promoted from D5 last season are now competing here: Last season’s D5 winners Beşiktaş JK (yamil Mc02, 74th) are finding their feet in 15th. D5 play-off winners Olympiacos (Ricardo Ferreira, 66th) have started well and sit 7th after hitting four goals last night.

At the bottom, Murilo’s Celta Vigo (new, 90th) are last, as their expected struggles materialise, joined by Sassuolo and Crystal Palace.

Division 5: Partizan Lead Tight Pack Chasing Promotion

Relative newcomer Marc Ques (79th historically) has Partizan setting the early pace (15 pts), followed closely by Bruno Neto^^‘s Lyon (14 pts, 83rd). The managers predicted to dominate, Gianluca Ghio (Independiente, 5th, 57th historically) and Ignazio Barraco (Marseille, 7th, 34th), find themselves in the chasing pack but haven’t asserted dominance yet. Independiente possess the division’s top scorer in Trincão (7 goals). Nick Wheels’ Spartak Moskva (3rd, 48th) are meeting their playoff prediction, with João Mário leading assists (6).

Perhaps most interestingly, the relegation picture defies Malcolm’s Stats. Predicted strugglers Atalanta (Chris Taylor, 80th), Chievo (Carlos Azevedo, 86th), and Athletic Club (Wayne Bullough, 45th) are currently safe. Instead, Santos (Paolo Everland, 84th), Bordeaux (Sheene Ralspunsky, 81st – actively signing players), and PSV (Chris East, 57th) find themselves unexpectedly in the bottom three.

Overall Conclusion (Early Stages)

After just six games, Season 25 is proving highly competitive and often unpredictable, challenging many pre-season expectations based on Malcolm’s Stats and even historical manager performance. While some favourites like Leverkusen are delivering, others like West Brom, Sevilla, Dortmund, and reigning D1 champions Hellas Verona are significantly underperforming. Standout individuals like Rodrygo (D1), Schick (D2), and Trincão (D5) are lighting up their divisions. Teams like Dnipro and Werder Bremen are providing early surprise packages. With 32 games still to play, there’s ample time for fortunes to change, but the initial phase has certainly provided plenty of talking points and suggests that reputation and predictions count for little once the whistle blows.