D3: River Top, Samp Sunk! (Matchday 6)








D2: McKenzie Laments Loss As United Take Top Spot (Matchday 6)

Huge win for us, starting to get our season on track.

Andrew Bailey (AC Milan)

We had a feeling this was a banana skin, and although not at our best we should have seen out the game once Cavani put us in front. We will put the point on the board and move on to Sunday.

Glen Mullan (RCD Espanyol)


Soundly beaten against a strong Levante team. They overpowered us in the final 25 minutes with 2 goals and another disallowed. Motm Vlahovic was unplayable.

Carl Martin (TSG 1899 Hoffenheim)


D1: Old Lady Dreams, Harmer Nightmares Continue (Matchday 6)

Slowball still doing the job I see. Well done Ash, gratz on the win mate. FC Porto only won once in 6 league matches this season, but it's still a great result for Valencia I André Guerraguess. I'll need to find motivation somewhere, somehow.

André Guerra (FC Porto)

Another strong display by the team, to be on 18 points and to only so far conceded 2 goals has been more than we could have dreamed of.

kevin mcgregor (Juventus)




World Club Cup (Preliminary Round)






Fictional Extra Time (FET) and Away Goals

In the knockout stages of friendly competitions (i.e., the Youth Cup and Shield, and the World Club Cup and Shield), if the scores are level at full-time, we follow standard rules for deciding the winners.

One Leg Ties

Fictional Extra Time decides the winner:

  • One goal scored for the team with most possession.
  • One goal scored for the team with the most shots on target.
  • One goal scored for the team who scored first in normal time.

If scores are still level, the team with the most "possession + shots on target" gets one extra goal (see original FET rule: https://smtop100.blog/youth-cup-format-rules/youth-cup-knock-out/)

Two Leg Ties

The team with the most Away Goals is the winner.

If the tie is still level (i.e., both legs ended with the same scoreline), then Fictional Extra Time in the second leg decides the winner, as above.


Admin Diary 2

It was a busy few days earlier this month.

New Player Concerns Rule

We had the Player Concerns vote, in which 92 out of 100 managers voted within two days, surely a record turnout.

We used a new voting service called Strawpoll, recommended by Beddows. One of the features of Strawpoll is that you can set it up so that you are guaranteed "one manger, one vote", and that it's anonymous (i.e., a secret ballot). True direct democracy!

The result was 51 managers in favour of a new rule from next season whereby any players reaching Level 3 concerns MUST be sold to an external club. 41 voted against. One manager abstained from voting (he couldn't decide). One manager quit (Partizan). One manager was sick and hadn't been able to login. Of the remaining five, four later told me they would also have voted in favour of the new rule. Only one manager I didn't get a final response from despite repeated efforts.

The result caused quite a bit of controversy. A few people feel very strongly one way or the other. There was a 100 plus comment thread on the newsfeed, although by my reckoning there were contributions from just 12 managers.

At the end of the day, the new rule simply brings forward by two levels the time by which managers need to either start playing unhappy players, or sell them. Which is exactly how player concerns are designed to work, and very similar to how things work in real life football management.

We'll see how it goes next season. If it proves to be controversial in practice, then we can have a second vote at the end of Season 22 to see if we want to continue with this new rule.

New Manager Appointments

While all this was going on, Dan W quit as manager of Barcelona, which also stirred up a lot of controversy. As well as the small matter of appointing a new manager to one of the biggest and the most successful club in Top 100 history. And the knock-on effect of appointing new managers to the clubs that became available after that. Mike T also quit Internacional.

In the end, it was Adam who left Villa to take the Barcelona job. It was a very close vote between Adam and two other managers. Jamie H quit Manchester City shortly after, which meant that we were able to appoint two real life fans to Villa and City - King Kev to Villa and Alex, returning for what must surely be his final chance at City. Paul M left Celta Vigo for Internacional, and Attila left Atalanta for Galatasaray. We appointed three returning Top 100 managers from Top 120 to the vacant posts at Celta, Atalanta and Crystal Palace - welcome back to Walter, Feargal and Greg.

Future Votes

I hope to run more polls with Strawpoll. It's pretty easy to set up. But to use the "one manager, one vote", secure anonymous voting feature really requires me to have every manager's email address, so that I can paste them all into the Strawpoll settings and then it automatically emails everyone with each individual vote. That's why I've asked people to complete a from to be included in what is in effect a new Top 100 Managers' Panel. You don't have to be on it, but if you want a vote on new rules, changes to rules, manager awards, etc. then you need to be.

Back Page Headlines

The last week or so, everyone seems to have settled into the new season, and I for one am loving all the match previews and manager reactions after the results come in on Thursday and Sunday nights (or Friday and Sunday mornings). If you haven't seen it already, I've been using some of these to compile Back Page headlines for each matchday. So keep them coming.

New Blog Updates

Finally, I'm trying to revamp the blog a bit to keep it up to date, lively, and to make it more user friendly and easier to find what you're looking for. And big thanks to Gav for redesigning the Top 100 logo and banner on the blog and on our Facebook page. It will take a while. Any suggestions and contributions are always welcome.

The Clubcall feature is pretty neat. It's like a blog for each team. You can check out updates and history of many (but not all) Top 100 clubs there (e.g., Espanyol). If your club isn't there, or there's not much to see, get posting (and if you need help posting, please ask for help - like most things, it's easy enough when you know how to do it).


Top 100 Cup Back Pages (1st Round)











Top 100 Managers' Panel

[googleapps domain=“docs” dir=“forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScVq8z47WNYPVNfrVKBH7dH-o5Nn6TnAsS1qI0uwPPoE8BKQw/viewform” query=“embedded=true” width=“640” height=“1521” /]


NSFW! D3 Back Pages (Matchday 5)

Still taken from James McKenzie's VHS collection

Overall 5 points from 4 games isnt too bad but tomorrow is HUGE! We have lots of fitness concerns and a winnable cup tie on Tuesday - a cup run is something that is mega important to this clubs culture, ethos and history - as such expect wholesale changes ahead of tomorrow.

Sir Stephen Beddows (God) (Sampdoria)



Palace welcome Mönchengladbach to Selhurst Park this evening looking to add to the point picked up in Koln on Thursday. The home side look to be at full strength, the main issue will be who starts up front, unhappy Sorloth or in form Suarez, big decision.

⍟Greg Bilboaツ (Crystal Palace)

Looks like a home win maybe 2-0, good luck.

⭐️Ken Keeley⭐️ (Borussia Mönchengladbach)

A game that could easily have gone either way. The 3 points take us to 10th, however a tough trip to Zenit is up next for the Eagles.

⍟Greg Bilboaツ (Crystal Palace)

Playing a stronger team at their gaff I was expecting a 2 goal loss and that’s how it turned out. No goals in two now with our only scorer, Belotti, off target with a few chances so that’s a worry No other players scoring is also a worry. Stats fairly equal so maybe we were a little unlucky.

⭐️Ken Keeley⭐️ (Borussia Mönchengladbach)

Our easiest match so far this season, that's also 3 wins on the spin as we move up into 2nd. Our defence was outstanding as they didn't have a shot on target.

Jay Jones (River Plate)

We showed remarkable composure as we soaked up all the pressure thrown our way. And when opportunities arose we were clinical up front with Zaniolo scoring the only goal of the game. A big loss for the next game however as Rob Holding gets a red card.

Syed Shah (Ajax)

D5 Back Pages (Matchday 5)

Great win with the known recipe! Now you know our plan! Try and stop it!

Chris Baggio (Dynamo Kyiv)

Very strong result against the Russian side, Dennis coming in and scoring once and assisting two, lovely.

Daniel Wythe (Santos FC)

D4 Back Pages (Matchday 5)



D1 Back Pages (Matchday 5)




I was hoping the struggle could be over for FC Porto after a good win past Thursday, but it's not. Failed to beat a clearly lower rated Aston Villa side at home tonight, 1-1 was the score. Conceded our opponent's only shot on target unfortunately. Ederson is being useless. On the other hand, we could only score 1 out of 7. . . So another 2 points dropped and already 10 points behind 1st place. Disappointing stuff. There's always next match. And next season. . .

André Guerra (FC Porto)

Great performance tonight, 15 points from 15, what a start.

kevin mcgregor (Juventus)

Dominated possession, but both sides with just the 2 shots on target. The Baggies shot went in.

Alex McLean (Manchester City)

D2 Back Pages (Matchday 5)




Psg drop to 2nd on goal difference after losing 3 2 at Sao Paulo. No complaints though as we gave it a go coming from 2 0 down to equalise but overall we were beaten by a better side. On to the cups next with a tough fixture against Anderlecht.

Andrew Kelly (Paris Saint-Germain)


World Club Cup Draw S21

If you're in our FB group you can watch or rewatch the full glory of the video draw.

If not, you'll have to make do with this fancy graphic. (If you don't see your team, you have a bye into the 2nd Round.)

Those of you who are unhappy with the draw, or the way it was carried out, or with the format of the competition, you will be pleased (or not) to know that we propose to hold a redraw later in the season.


Verratti justifying managers faith

When Espanyol agreed to sell generational defender Antonio Silva this close season, it raised a few eye brows. Joining in his place was Balogun, Engels and experienced Midfield maestro Verratti.

Verratti may have just moved to Qatar and may be looking at a rating drop, however in the first five games this season, he is already repaying the managers faith by controlling the midfield battle in Division 2.

Described by his former boss James Mckenzie as a "rollsroyce" , he is certainly living up to that title. Two assist, Two player of the match awards and a average rating of 7.4 from the first five fixtures, has certainly aided Espanyol to sit a point off the leaders at this early stage and create some optimism , given they were predicted to finish 19th this season.

The club have already reached an agreement to bring another experienced player in place of Balogun, with Sadio Mane to join in November, as they look to keep momentum going.

"When all the dust settles, you can't beat having experienced players who carry a good rating. We've seen a big shift to young players in the game world, whilst the Saudi, Qatar and MSL leagues have been snapping up some of the worlds biggest names, To further complicate the thought process. We've seen this an opportunity to compliment our youth set up, by boosting our first team with some solid players and ratings, which really has us sitting pretty. We are not worried about having to find buyers or replacements for these players, as we already have them sat in our 35 strong youth team. This season we've been able to loan out youth players with a rating of 85, due to them not making our first 11 for our youth Cup campaign, which is how we are measuring our progress. Verratti is producing exactly what we thought he would, and along with Muller and Mane, our first 11 is looking strong in key areas. We have looked at bringing another experienced head in this past week, and although talks have been far too slow, we will continue to explore options"


D5 Back Pages (Matchday 4)


5 goals in 3 Bundesliga matches, we hope he'll continue this way.

Gianluca Ghio (Independiente)

Down to 9th, and against 8th placed Kazan next, important game.

Daniel Wythe (Santos FC)

We could score more goals at the end.

Chris Baggio (Dynamo Kyiv)

D4 Back Pages (Matchday 4)

This will be my first game in charge since my recent return to Top 100. I have made a few alterations to the squad, too many in fact and am beginning a transfer ban as a result. I’ll put my hand up and admit I took my eye off the ball, onwards and upwards . #forzaatalanta ☘️

feargal Hickey (Atalanta BC)

We are still looking to move out our last none Spanish based or Spanish nationality players in our first team, we have 5/6 players including Lang, all can leave for Spanish players in return. Would like to have all sold by end of the day. PM or put in an offer, I could give all 5/6 players for 1 or 2 of yours also, all positions considered but a CB or CM of higher rating would be nice.

Mike Scallotti (Málaga CF)

I have to look for signings for the defence because my defence is in a mess.

Sheene Ralspunsky (Feyenoord)

D3 Back Pages (Matchday 4)





Willing to pack a couple or more and maybe others for one of yours. PM me if interested.

The Special Gyan (Internazionale)

I will be open to deals on most players after I've had chance to review the squad and see them in action, apologies for those offers rejected so far, rather than message each one of you I'll let you know on here. After Thursday and Sundays games I'd reckon I'll be in a better spot for negotiating.

⍟Greg Bilboaツ (Crystal Palace)

I was expecting to win this one so I was very disappointed. Stats in their favour so well done Jay on a nice win. Mid table now. LEARN AND MOVE ON.

⭐️Ken Keeley⭐️ (Borussia Mönchengladbach)

If it wasn't for one of the rarest sights in Soccer Manager - a free kick goal after a yellow card - in the first minute, perhaps the outcome could be different.

Hugos Monkides (Sassuolo)

Fair result in the end, Koln had more possession, Palace more chances, everything else virtually identical. . . Pretty happy with a point away from home in the first game in charge.

⍟Greg Bilboaツ (Crystal Palace)

Great victory against Inter… Sunderland is on fire…


D2 Back Pages (Matchday 4)

Big win for us as we beat Spurs away 3-2, squad down to 43, no internal transfers done since taking over & we wont do any unless we like the deals, a great start to the season and promotion is our aim.

mark stewart (Udinese Calcio)

Looking back on some of the attempts we probably deserved the win but couldn’t get a 2nd to kill of the game , keeps us unbeaten for the season.

Scott Mckenzie (São Paulo FC)

This was a tough match, when you see Casemiro and Paqueta lining up against you, you know you are in for a battle. We weathered the early storm and our big players produced. It's been an excellent start to the season, and I'm pleased with the progress the squad is making.

Glen Mullan (RCD Espanyol)

Milners adaptability may prove crucial in the long season ahead,

Various talks regarding Moreno and more so Fekir over the past 24 hours but nothing more to report.

Niall Taylor (Manchester United)

Left back Fran Garcia will miss half the season though after breaking his ankle and Sinisterra joins Grifo on the injured list also.

Andrew Bailey (AC Milan)

D1 Back Pages (Matchday 4)







Even match possession wise but had much more of the other stats. Great start to the season.

Gregg Robinson (SL Benfica)

Results have not been great so far but we kept fighting, changing some tactics and some players and even offering some new contracts this week to boost our players moral, shake things up and change our luck! Glad we could bounce back tonight with a solid win, hopefully we can pick up some form now. Vamos Porto!

André Guerra (FC Porto)

Not a lot in it regarding stats and chances, Juventus were just more clinical, delighted with the start, 12 points, 4 wins, 9 goals scored and 1 against. Roll on to the next tuff game.

kevin mcgregor (Juventus)